The Lancaster Heritage Chorale will be presenting their final concert for the 2024 Christmas season in our sanctuary at 4:00 pm on Sunday, January 5, 2025. This is a wonderful way to spend a cold winter afternoon. If you have never attended one of the Chorale’s concerts you are in for a treat.
Holy Spirit Lutheran Church, 3131 Columbia Ave., Lancaster, PA 17603
A couple months ago I was excited to see that a new movie was coming out that had Bonhoeffer as its central figure. Now, Bonhoeffer is a notoriously challenging figure to pin down. And he was active during a time in our history that was very complex. So we decided to prepare ourselves for this by digging into a series called Theologians Under Hitler. For those of you who participated in that we had our eyes opened about how the church became sometimes reluctantly complicit and other times enthusiastically complicit in the Nazi agenda. We had some of our questions answered about how this could happen. Move forward a few months and now the movie is out and I am profoundly disappointed. Let me tell you why.
Fifteen years ago, Stephen Haynes examined the varied interpretations of Dietrich Bonhoeffer, the German theologian whose legacy is often contested. Was Bonhoeffer a conservative longing to restore Germany or a progressive challenging dogmatic traditions? Was he a church-focused thinker or an activist prioritizing social action? His complex writings, sermons, and correspondence defy easy categorization and often reflect more about those interpreting him than about Bonhoeffer himself.
The new film Bonhoeffer: Pastor. Spy. Assassin. exemplifies this problem, turning Bonhoeffer into a malleable figure serving modern political narratives. Produced by Angel Studios, the film portrays him as a theologian-turned-political agent, sacrificing theological convictions for espionage and activism.
While the film’s biographical elements—Bonhoeffer’s education, time at Union Theological Seminary, resistance to the Nazis, and eventual execution—are accurate, the narrative exaggerates and dramatizes his life. For instance, Bonhoeffer’s year in New York and his exposure to racism become scenes of him leading a jazz band and confronting racist violence. His underground seminary, intended to train clergy, is framed as a hub for political rebellion.
As the film progresses, Bonhoeffer disavows pacifism, prioritizing Hitler’s assassination over his theological principles. This portrayal misrepresents historical evidence. While Bonhoeffer likely knew of assassination plots, his writings suggest his resistance remained grounded in faith and nonviolence—helping smuggle Jews and sharing Nazi intelligence through church networks.
By framing Bonhoeffer as an assassin, the film sacrifices historical nuance for drama, aligning its narrative with Eric Metaxas’ controversial biography. Both the movie and Metaxas emphasize political action over Bonhoeffer’s deeper convictions, reshaping his legacy into a template for modern ideological battles.
In reality, Bonhoeffer’s life demonstrated steadfast Christian resistance, even in the face of immense pressure to compromise. His writings, including reflections on loving enemies and standing by Christ’s teachings, challenge the film’s narrative of moral flexibility.
Rather than glorifying political violence or theological radicalism, Bonhoeffer’s story reminds us of the church’s call to faithfulness over political expedience. By focusing on this, the film could have offered a powerful example of Christian courage in tumultuous times—something sorely needed today.
So, feel free to go see the movie if you like. But if you do, I also hope you will join us for Sunday School. In the new year, we will dive deeply into this fascinating figure over six sessions.
Lessons from Dietrich Bonhoeffer in a House Divided and a World on Fire
Join us for 6 weeks as we explore the life and theology of Dietrich Bonhoeffer, and the lessons we can use as we live at the intersection of faith and civic life today. Bonhoeffer was a Lutheran pastor and theologian living in Nazi Germany, who eventually joined the resistance and was arrested and killed before the end of WWII. This curriculum was compiled by Dr. Lori Brandt Hale, an internationally renowned Bonhoeffer scholar and president of the International Bonhoeffer Society – English Language Section. Lutheran Advocacy Ministry in Pennsylvania is a partner in distributing to congregations to inspire deeper conversation and discernment about how we live as disciples.
As we enter November, gratitude becomes a natural theme woven into our lives. Surrounded by the beauty of fall, we’re reminded of the many blessings God provides daily, both seen and unseen. Gratitude is not just a feeling but a choice we make to see God’s hand in every part of our journey.
This month, we’re reflecting on what it means to live with a heart of gratitude. Gratitude invites us to find joy in small moments, to recognize the strength we gain from challenges, and to see each person in our lives as a gift. Ephesians 5:20 reminds us to “give thanks always and for everything to God the Father.” When we cultivate gratitude, we grow closer to God and are better equipped to share His love with others.
Our church community has several opportunities this month to express and live out gratitude. Join us for our next Second Sunday event. We will be expressing our gratitude to our service members by taking up a collection of care items for patients at the Lebanon VA hospital. We are also putting our Help Thy Neighbor Fund to use with a donation to the Food Hub. The Food Hub along with area congregations are working on addressing the acute homelessness issue in downtown Lancaster. Some of these funds will be used to connect our houseless neighbors to much needed resources such as porta potties as we wait for the shelter construction at Otterbein Methodist Church to be finished. I am grateful for your generosity and the ability we have to be able to respond to urgent needs such as this.
Gratitude is contagious—it lifts us, strengthens us, and brings us closer to one another and to God. Let us carry this heart of gratitude into every day, allowing it to transform the way we live, give, and worship.
The Church office is planning to update our directory of Congregation members. Please fill out the form with your contact info. If you prefer to submit your own photo (either as individuals or as a family), please include one here. If you have questions, please contact Tim Brixius at brix11@gmail.com.
We will be offering to take photos after upcoming services on Nov. 17.
